View the profiles of professionals named tim williamson on linkedin. Timothy williamson tw has been the wykeham professor of. This article appeared in philosophical topics 281 spring. Eubulides is also standardly credited with the formulation of the sorites. Joseph maddux, district attorney sonoma county, for respondent.
Vagueness timothy williamson vagueness provides the first comprehensive examination of a topic of increasing importance in metaphysics and the philosophy of logic and language. His books include vagueness routledge, 1994, knowledge and its limits oxford, 2000, and the philosophy of philosophy blackwell, 2007. Vagueness, as timothy williamson 1994, 2007 conceives it, is an epistemic phe nomenon that can be characterized in terms of absence of knowledge. According to timothy williamson, there is an exact point when every pile ceases to be a pile, and we could never know what that point is. The classical theory implies that every complex concept has a classical analysis, where a classical. Below are chegg supported textbooks by stephen d williamson. Williamsons epistemic view of vagueness has now come to occupy the front stage. In 1984 i was in materiel acquisition management, known as mam, which was the precursor to the acquisition corps. View timothy williamson research papers on academia. Timothy williamson, university of oxford, philosophy department, faculty member. We get along well enough applying the word heap on the basis of casual impressions.
Fuzzy logic and higherorder vagueness theory and logic group. Timothy williamson attempts to give a satisfying account of vagueness as. The fact is whether a law is vague or precise depends on how we wish to administer justice. Emerson hall harvard university 25 quincy street cambridge, ma 028 phone. An interview with timothy williamson timothy williamson tw has been the wykeham professor of logic at oxford since 2000. Its a heritage that many generations have passed on from father to son, grandfather to son to grandson, said dino beckett, do, ceo of the williamson health and wellness center and board chair of williamson redevelopment authority.
Greek word for bald and is attributed to eubulides of miletus, a contemporary of. Direct reference and vague identity in 1957, reporters asked maverick producer mike todd why he bought a huge 29carat engagement ring for elizabeth taylor. The classic argument against worldly vagueness in identity can be found in evans 1978 and salmon 1981. We must try to discover whether an appropriate account of this quality would permit us to combine the following views. Studies philosophy, philosophy of language, and epistemology. Vagueness provides the first comprehensive examination of a topic of increasing importance in metaphysics and the philosophy of logic and language.
The classical theory of concepts internet encyclopedia of. Varieties of vagueness in the law usc gould school of law. Todd answered thirty carats would have been vulgar. Contextualism and the factivity problem1 peter baumann abstract epistemological contextualism the claim that the truth value of knowledgeattributions can vary with the context of the attributor has recently faced a whole series of objections. Alexander williamson, an inmate of the sonoma county jail, by this proceeding in habeas corpus seeks his release from confinement. Tetralogue isnt a robust philosophical argument, but cause greats insights in those that are familiar with philosophy. Williamson on knowledge and psychological explanation. It traces the history of philosophical work on vagueness, evaluates the. Timothy williamson oxford university abstract this paper explains and defends the idea that metaphysical necessity is the strongest kind of objective necessity. Timothy williamson on necessary existents july 26, 2007 richard brown 3 comments in the discussion of my post i necessarily exist jason zari pointed out timothy williamsons paper necessary existants as a way of explaining how he was led to questions about logic and the proof of necessary existence.
The linguistic turn has subsequently become a standard vague phrase for a diffuse event some regard it as. The most serious one, however, has not been discussed much so far. Williamsons many necessary existents theodore sider analysis 69 2009. The next response is expressed as follows by williamson. By reversing the usual explanatory order and putting knowledge. Williamson 1994, chapter 9 discusses an epistemicist account of vague objects. The case against the final strategy provides positive grounds for thinking that the principle should hold good in such situations.
On the denial of bivalence is absurd1 francis jeffry pelletier robert j. The next section considers a different objection to the epistemic view, and makes another application of the concept of supervenience. Williamsons arguments are aimed to deliver a onetwo punch to opponents. They are criticized as false, uninformative, irrelevant, insincere, unwarranted, illphrased, or rude. Timothy williamson 1994 traces the ignorance of the threshold for childhood to margin for error principles. If you keep removing single grains of sand from a heap, when is it no longer a heap. Gives a new account of the relation between incommensurability and vagueness. How deep is the distinction between a priori and a posteriori knowledge. The epistemic view of vagueness is consistent with the supervenience of vague facts on precise ones. Pdf on oct 1, 1998, timothy williamson and others published. Tony williamson in virginia va 2 records found whitepages. This paper considers, and rejects, three strategies aimed at showing that the kkprinciple fails even in most favourable circumstances all emerging from williamsons knowledge and its limits. Williamson is a professor at cornell university in the school of operations research and information engineering. Jul 26, 2007 timothy williamson on necessary existents july 26, 2007 richard brown 3 comments in the discussion of my post i necessarily exist jason zari pointed out timothy williamsons paper necessary existants as a way of explaining how he was led to questions about logic and the proof of necessary existence.
Knowing and asserting timothy williamson assertions are praised as true, informative, relevant, sincere, warranted, wellphrased, or polite. On vagueness, or, when is a heap of sand not a heap of sand. Timothy williamson traces the history of this philosophical problem from discussions of the heap paradox in classical greece to modern formal approaches such as fuzzy logic. If a man loses a certain number of hairs, he will be bald, and just one hair makes the difference. The paper argues that, although a distinction between a priori and a posteriori knowledge or justification can be drawn, it is a superficial one, of little theoretical significance. Nice guys in show business usually have a modest way of explaining success. Heller 1996 objects to worldly vagueness of all kinds. A shared history, a sustainable solution coal has been such a large part of our community.
Oxford university press vagueness i semantic scholar. We found 2 records for tony williamson in south boston, blue ridge and 3 other cities in virginia. Backstage with andy williams 59 a visit with a popular recording star who is riding the wave of his nightclub success to a top slot in television. Recently, timothy williamson williamson, 2000 has argued that this view is erroneous that knowledge does play a role in ordinary psychological explanation. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Abstract vagueness provides the first comprehensive examination of a topic of increasing importance in metaphysics and the philosophy of logic and language. Vagueness in the law, as elsewhere, comes in different forms. Nov 28, 2014 williamson, in my point of view, did a great job. Todds quip absurdly implies he knew that 30 carats is the. Bibliography on modality and possible worlds ted sider. The kkprinciple, margins for error, and safety springerlink. The philosophy of philosophy timothy williamson download. Hudson 2000 defends an epistemicist temporal parts theory. He maintains the vagueness of the vernacular, but still conduce the reader during a great journey.
Successful doctoral theses supervised at least in large part by timothy williamson maria baghramian, logic, language and relativism university of dublin, 1990 joao branquinho, direct reference, cognitive significance and fregean sense university of. I was in the acquisition corps before there was an acquisition corps. Timothy williamson on necessary existents richard brown. The classical theory of concepts is one of the five primary theories of concepts, the other four being prototype or exemplar theories, atomistic theories, theorytheories, and neoclassical theories. Contextualism and the factivity problem swarthmore college. A good case can be made that the law ought to be vague i. Williamson s epistemic view of vagueness has now come to occupy the front stage. From discussions of the heap paradox in classical greece, to modern formal approaches like fuzzy logic, timothy williamson traces the history of the problem of vagueness. What do you do and why is it important to the warfighter. Timothy williamson is the author of identity and discrimination blackwell 1990, updated edition 20, vagueness routledge 1994, knowledge and its limits oxford 2000, the philosophy of philosophy blackwell 2007, modal logic as metaphysics oxford 20, tetralogue oxford 2015 and about two hundred articles. The second volume in the blackwell brown lectures in philosophy, this volume offers an original and provocative take on the nature and methodology of philosophy based on public lectures at brown university, given by the preeminent philosopher, timothy williamson. The standard way to avoid these consequences is to weaken the theory of quanti cation to a certain kind of free logic. Aug, 2011 this paper considers, and rejects, three strategies aimed at showing that the kkprinciple fails even in most favourable circumstances all emerging from williamsons knowledge and its limits. My main purpose in this essay is to distinguish between different types of vagueness in the legal context, and to explain their rationales.
But if the local council charged you with having dumped a heap of sand in a public place, and you denied that it amounted to a heap, whether you had to pay a large fine might depend on the meaning of the word heap. This article appeared in philosophical topics 281 spring 200. However, mayor williams says that the plan is doomed to failure. Timothy williamson, in various places, has put forward an argument that is supposed to show. How deep is the distinction between a priori and a posteriori. Pennsylvania state university, 328 reber building, university park, pa 16802 work phone. Timothy williamson traces the history of this philosophical problem from discussions of the heap paradox in classical greece to modern formal. Your use of the jstor archive indicates your acceptance of. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. His books include vagueness rout ledge, 1994, knowledge and. Williamson on evidence and knowledge the university of michigan timothy williamsons knowledge and its limits is a treasure trove of philosophical riches.
1424 1343 1539 1131 196 693 729 436 1511 552 588 60 698 435 934 292 1326 721 150 275 914 748 756 598 430 466 1534 196 219 1181 667 1309 1349 469 474 110 246 673 663 650 1201 198